Brands

Mise à jour 01/03/2023

Brands’ social and environmental responsibility: illusion or reality? (version anglaise)

Image
Eurazeo views brands
26/01/2023 - 5 mins

Despite tough inflationary times, there is still demand for brand name products, but real concerns about ESG considerations among consumers on both sides of the Atlantic are putting new pressure on companies to live up to expectations. Amandine Ayrem and David Choi look at how private equity firms can work with their portfolio companies to navigate the new demands.

 

Brands’ social and environmental responsibility: illusion or reality? 

As inflation bites in varying degrees on each side of the Atlantic, investors looking for brand name companies need to take account of the different ways that consumers are adapting to tough times.

The driving idea behind consumer growth investing has long been to identify quality brands and products that consumers want to be associated with and for which they are willing to make an extra effort. The notion that people might pay a bit more for a product with which they have some sense of connection – and which they enjoy seeing, touching, tasting, and feeling – has long driven a trend toward premiumization.

Today’s inflationary pressures haven’t halted that trend, but recent experience shows us that it is taking different forms in different markets. In the US market, for example, we even see cases of premiumization reaching into some lower price-tag “everyday” items, such as beverage mixers or pet food. Although higher energy and food prices eat into consumers’ discretionary spend, some are willing to preserve or even marginally increase their outlay on some smaller, but still upmarket, items, thereby offering themselves a modest and permissible luxury in tougher times.

The focus for investors in those companies remains the same: identifying growing brands that can continue to successfully differentiate themselves, for example through quality and traceability of product, an authentic back-story, or conveniently available where the consumer is already shopping. Those products are likely to be the ones that can boast of a certain “inelasticity”, meaning that demand is not significantly affected by a change in price, or even a “positive price-elasticity”, like in the luxury sector, with an increase in price resulting in a higher demand.

In Europe, the combined pressure of higher prices for food and energy is weighing even more heavily on consumers, forcing many households to make some tough choices as they review their discretionary spending patterns. The impact of this situation shows up in some telling details as, for example, Netflix struggling for the first time and massively loosing subscribers. Even more telling, the post-Covid surge of demand for “organic” and “authentic” foods and products has recently fallen off sharply, a glaring contradiction to people’s continued expressions of concern for the environment, responsible sourcing, and good governance.

This almost schizophrenic state-of-mind among European consumers is in fact quite understandable. The visible, everyday impact of climate change has raised concerns among many, especially the young, about the state of the world they are living in. European consumers tend to take a relatively sophisticated view of the world and are often ahead of the regulators in terms of their purchasing behavior. However, when times get tough and reality is challenging, they are more reluctant to pay for the cost of environmental-friendly, responsible production and packaging. Tangible measures to match ESG requirements - such as introducing traceability, carbon neutrality or plastic-free packaging - all have a cost, but end-consumers don’t necessarily want to see that cost pushed down the line for them to pick up.

 

European consumers demanding a greater social role from corporates

This difficulty and resistance by consumers to shoulder the costs of corporate responsibility is an important reason behind the recent shift we have witnessed in European consumers’ ESG concerns.

For a long time, European ESG concerns focused on the E-for-environment. Today the S-for-social is rising in importance too: consumers are coming from health, post Covid lockdowns, to wealth worries. Recent trends show that European consumers are becoming more critical of corporations’ behavior on issues that were previously predominantly seen as the concerns of politicians, such as profit-sharing, salaries, reshoring and sovereignty. Brands are increasingly expected to take over in solving societal issues.

For investors in European brands, this broader consumer focus on corporate social responsibility means they need to factor in the cost of integrating ESG criteria as essential transversal elements of any company’s business plan. This will in turn impact a buyout fund’s investment thesis, knowing that there is a cost in deploying ESG which cannot be entirely passed onto the end-customer, but which is fundamental to sustain, and even increase, the value of a company over the time.

This newly contradictory approach as to who should pay to maintain standards can also help answer the question for European brand investors of where they should be seeking value. The answer is likely to focus on the edges of the value spectrum and to avoid the middle ground. On one end of the scale, the wealthy classes who feel more insulated from the effects of inflation will continue to spend on luxury items. At the other end of the scale, cheaper “value” options will attract a growing number of the middle-income consumers as they find themselves forced to trade down.

 

US consumers saying one thing, buying another

Like their European counterparts, US consumers are also displaying a degree of split-personality when it comes to ESG concerns, often holding opinions in direct contradiction to their purchasing patterns. For example, surveys show that young consumers often express real concerns about product quality, responsible sourcing, and transparency in the supply chain but will then buy cheaper items they can find online.

Despite sharing concerns about saving money in tough times, US consumers differ in one important way from their European counterparts in their attitudes to ESG. In the US, the most visible element of consumer-driven ESG focus continues to be diversity and inclusion, which – although growing – remains much less prominent a factor in Europe.

This means that US investors looking for opportunities among consumer companies must take this powerful D&I awareness into account, looking not just for brands that have mastered the “omnichannel” trends in retail sales, but which also reflect consumers’ own sense and respect for differentiation.

Those differences notwithstanding, as today’s troubled environment puts new pressures on consumers everywhere, investors on both sides of the Atlantic need to keep their eye on certain tried-&-true management principles as they help steer their portfolio companies to profitable growth. An experienced and responsible but nimble management team that is focused on customers’ needs and journey, quality, innovation and increased productivity will, as always, prove to be the most important factor in building resilient brands that consumers will continue to trust and to buy.

À lire aussi

Vignette
Eurazeoviews2-Flak-Teisseire

19/09/2023 - TRIBUNE

The era of the adaptation economy, and the need for a common ESG benchmark

4 min

Vignette
Eurazeoviews2-Girard-morin

19/09/2023 - TRIBUNE

Making the most of ESG reporting

4 min

Vignette
Eurazeoviews-lambry-makaya

19/09/2023 - TRIBUNE

Towards a cleaner, more sustainable shipping industry

3 min

Vignette
Eurazeoviews2-Mombert-Sesboue-Meignen

19/09/2023 - TRIBUNE

A promising future for Tech M&A

5 min

Vignette
Eurazeoviews2-Cohen Devillard

19/09/2023 - TRIBUNE

Decarbonising cities: the New Electricity Era

6 min

Vignette
Eurazeoviews Orsi - Cassam - Lariviere - Zins

19/09/2023 - TRIBUNE

The revolution in the healthcare sector

5 min

Image
eurazeoviews-2-doat-bertay-debock

19/09/2023 - TRIBUNE

Responsibly addressing the opportunities of Gen AI

5 min

Vignette
Eurazeoviews-agathe-bubbe

19/09/2023 - TRIBUNE

Democratization of private equity: the way forward

4 min

Vignette
visuel Virginie Morgon

25/01/2023 - TRIBUNE

Responsible investing – a powerful tool for better growth (version anglaise)

6 min

Vignette
Tribune Sophie Flak zoé Fabian

26/01/2023 - TRIBUNE

Europe’s sustainable tech sector draws intense investor interest (version anglaise)

3 min

Vignette
Christophe Bavière Tribune

26/01/2023 - TRIBUNE

After the euphoria: Eurazeo's strengths in a challenging market (version anglaise)

5 min

Vignette
Eurazeo views tribune décarbonisation

26/01/2023 - TRIBUNE

Why is Europe ahead in decarbonizing the economy? (version anglaise)

5 min

Vignette
Eurazeo views Christophe Simon

26/01/2023 - TRIBUNE

The rise of GP-led transactions (version anglaise)

4 min

Vignette
Eurazeo views tribune SMES

26/01/2023 - TRIBUNE

Growth prospects remain intact for European SMEs (version anglaise)

4 min

Vignette
Eurazeo views tribune 4

26/01/2023 - TRIBUNE

Private debt: an investment partner even in challenging economic times (version anglaise)

4 min

Vignette
Eurazeo views vignette 3

26/01/2023 - TRIBUNE

Biotechs, the ultimate post-pandemic winners? (version anglaise)

5 min

Vignette
visuel tribune eurazeo views 1

26/01/2023 - TRIBUNE

European sovereignty: myth or reality? (version anglaise)

4 min

Vignette
Tribune Caroline Hadrbolec

16/11/2022 - TRIBUNE

Féminisation des métiers : la parité, accélérateur de performance

5 min

Image
Image - tribune on democratizing private equity by Virginie Morgon

08/11/2022 - TRIBUNE

Démocratisation : la nouvelle frontière à franchir pour le private equity

5 min

Vignette
visuel Virginie Morgon

30/09/2022 - TRIBUNE

L’avènement des plateformes de marchés privés

4 min

Vignette
Vignette Laurent Chatelin

22/09/2022 - TRIBUNE

Les infrastructures au cœur de la transition écologique

4 min

Vignette
Tribune Amandine Ayrem

17/03/2022 - TRIBUNE

Les grands enjeux RSE de Carambar & Co

4 min

Vignette
Visuel Sophie Flak

16/06/2021 - TRIBUNE

NFRD, CFRD, SFRD, Taxonomie … kesako ?

6 min

Image
Tribune Virginie Morgon

02/06/2021 - TRIBUNE

Une nouvelle identité pour une nouvelle ambition

4 min

Vignette
Tribune Mathieu Baret

24/12/2020 - TRIBUNE

Agir pour le climat : ce que les investisseurs peuvent faire

4 min

Image
Tribune Sophie Flak

28/04/2021 - TRIBUNE

The Reason Why

2 min

Vignette
visuel Virginie Morgon tribune

07/04/2021 - TRIBUNE

Digital health: accélérer les innovations et les investissements (version anglaise)

5 min

Vignette
Visuel Virginie Morgon tribune 2

23/03/2021 - TRIBUNE

Le moment pour le private Equity est maintenant (version anglaise)

4 min

Vignette
Tribune Caroline Hadrbolec

08/03/2021 - TRIBUNE

Garantir un milieu de travail véritablement inclusif est la clé pour former les femmes vers le sommet

2 min

Vignette
Tribune Virginie Morgon

10/11/2020 - TRIBUNE

Une vue générale sur les challenges et opportunités du marché privés (version anglaise)

3 min

Vignette
visuel Virginie Morgon

30/09/2020 - TRIBUNE

Présentation du nouveau programme RSE pour les 20 prochaines années, O+ (version anglaise)

3 min

Vignette
visuel Virginie Morgon tribune

02/09/2020 - TRIBUNE

Stabilité et réactivité en temps de crise & dans quelle direction irons-nous après (version anglaise)

5 min

Vignette
Tribune Marc Frappier

04/06/2020 - TRIBUNE

Résumé sur la Chine (version anglaise)

4 min

Vignette
Visuel Virginie Morgon tribune 2

03/04/2020 - TRIBUNE

La solidarité nous donne de l'espoir face à la pandémie de Covid-19 (Version Anglaise)

2 min

Vignette
Tribune Benoist Grossmann

16/12/2019 - TRIBUNE

Encourager l’entreprenariat au féminin : 5 conseils pour réussir sa levée de fonds

5 min

Vignette
Tribune Virginie Morgon

15/08/2019 - TRIBUNE

L’évolution de l’économie globale a diversifié l’industrie du capital investissement (version anglaise)

4 min

Vignette
visuel Virginie Morgon

23/04/2019 - TRIBUNE

Diversification audacieuse : Un nouveau standard pour promouvoir la longevité et la prospérité (version anglaise)

3 min

Vignette
Visuel Virginie Morgon tribune 2

04/03/2019 - TRIBUNE

Un challenge audacieux pour le Private equity (Version Anglaise)

3 min

Vignette
visuel Virginie Morgon tribune

30/01/2019 - TRIBUNE

Comment le Private Equity conduit le changement dans le commerce de détail (version anglaise)

3 min

Alerte vigilance

Tentatives de fraude et d'usurpation d'identité